from the
Holy Land
from
Rabbi Ephraim Schwartz
"Your friend in Karmiel"
November 20th
2026 -Volume 17 Issue
7 10th of Kisleiv 5787
Parshat Vayeitzei
Click here below for print edition
(Weekly Newsletter - Parshat Vayeitzei 2026 )
Do you have an
escape plan? Have you given any thought to how you might get out? Where you
might go? What if the gates are closed? What will be the point when you say enough
is enough? There's no avoiding it anymore. It's time to pack, Rabbosai.
Honey, get the kids. Grab the passports. It's over. We're outa here. Have you
actually ever formulated those thoughts and ideas that I'm sure have flitted
through your brain at times and that you quickly pushed to the side, into a
real plan?
Now don't get me wrong. I'm not saying anything is imminent.
I'm not even saying your going to have to pick up in one minute in middle of
the night and flee. I don't think that will happen and I don't think you do as
well. Although… who knows? Yet, one thing I think we all can agree upon, you
ain't staying there forever. The game is going to be over soon. The clock is
ticking. I think we all feel it and know it. It ain't the same US of A and
"medina shel chesed" that we once were very comfortable in.
The future Presidential candidates on either side of the aisle aren't looking
too promising. It seems our tefillos of finally arriving at the end of
the Exile, of seeing the "last stop of Galus" finally conclude, are not
too far away. So I ask you again, do you have a plan? Have you given any serious
thought, about what you would do if that end is not just a pleasant one, with
wings of eagles and white bearded men on donkeys and flying shuls?
I ask because I know you're not a dumb or delusional
person. You plan things. You call me up months in advance even while there's a
war threatening here because you want to know what we're doing in three months
and where we will be eating lunch. You plan for your kid's future. You have
insurance policies. You put away money each month in your 401K for your
retirement. You don't like it when things just pounce up at you unexpectedly.
Your try to foresee things that may occur that might change your plans or mess
up your day. You have contingencies for most things in life.
As well, you know a bit of Jewish history. You know that we
never really are anywhere permanently. You know that historically when we got
to the peak of our comfort, integration, and political and social assimilation,
then Hashem gets annoyed. He gets the goyim to be annoyed and ultimately it
doesn't end well.
I'm not even talking about spiritual assimilation, like
those that try to blame the Holocaust on the secular assimilation of Berlin and
European Jews. We both know that plenty of Torah Jews who were unassimilated
and holy were murdered and were perhaps even the majority of them. Yeah… Torah
didn't protect them. They were comfortable. They learned, they had yeshivos,
they had spiritual holy lives. But it ends. Because it became time to move onto
the next stop. Perhaps even because Hashem wanted to establish a State of
Israel, by even secular Jews understanding on some basic level that other
places is not where we will ever have a home. Or not… You can debate that. But
ultimately, that's our history and you know it.
I think most of us though despite that like to think, that
we're living in a different world. Not to say that we won't get thrown out, or
that anti-Semitism isn't coming. But that we think that it's different in that
we won't have to flee. That' we'll have enough time when it happens to leave. That
we can never really get stuck or locked into the country and not be able to leave
when it really gets bad. I mean that can't really happen, right? There will
always be enough time. It's not the same as it once was in that aspect. So, I
don't really have to plan anything. When it really starts to get rough, dangerous
or scary, you'll have plenty of time to get out. Israel is always gonna be
there. So really… what do I need to plan for.
Now, this train of thought, is of course ignoring the fact that
the skies were shut down for a long time in America during Corona. They were
shut down for Israel as well, during a large part of the war. People were stuck
here and had to go through Egypt to get out. Which was kind of crazy. There was
this real helpless desperate sense of being stuck and locked in. But those were
freak incidents. That could never happen in real time. The skies can't be shut
down. The borders can't be closed. There couldn't be a big war that I was stuck
in and that saw my neighbors or perhaps politicians blame it on the Jews. Or
just take out their resentment and innate hatred for us. That can't really
happen. It will never be my circumstance. Sure, I know that's what the Jews of
Hungary said. Of Poland. Of France. It's what they said back in Spain. Back in
The Crusades. It's what we said in Jerusalem before the First and Second Temple
destruction.
Actually, during the Temple periods, they said we have
another ace in our pocket. We have the Temple. Hashem wouldn't burn down His
own house. Sure, we're not so observant… but ultimately the function of the
world is for Him to have a house down here. We have sacrifices and offerings.
He's not going to give that all up. It's kind of like today, when we say we
have Torah. That's what Hashem really wants. He doesn't care that we're not
living in Israel. That we're not trying to return and build a Bais Ha'Mikdash.
He's not gonna burn us down. Berlin is the new Jerusalem. So is Lita. So is
Volozhin. So is Spain. And Lakewood too…
Ok… I'll back off for a moment. Let's go the parsha. Let's
hit the parsha of galus and leaving galus. The parsha of Yaakov, the man and
symbol of Torah and how he leaves and takes his children out of Exile. It's an important
parsha because our sages tell us that ma'aseh avos siman la'banim- the
actions of our patriarchs are a fore hearkening of what will ultimately happen to
their descendants. What happened to our ancestors when they ultimately left Egypt?
What happens whenever we leave galus? What will happen to us today…?
If you don't believe me, just check it out. Here we have
Yaakov, just as we have his descendants Yosef and the tribes of Israel living
in Exile in a foreign country. They come as paupers, they're on the flee from
persecution. Yet, very quickly they pick themselves up. They settle, they prosper,
they become the leading upper class. Yet when that happens, the tide turns. In
Yaakov's case it was after 20 years, in his descendants it was 210 years. The
goyim are looking at us differently. They accuse us of stealing from them. In
Pharoah's case it was us joining with the enemy in case of war. Hmmm… Iran. needless
war… And then we have to escape. We have to leave. We have to leave fast.
In Yaakov and in Egypt it's in middle of the night, when
our enemies are otherwise occupied. In both cases the Torah uses the word barach-
we ran away and escaped, the Baal Haturim notes. We travel three days. They run
after us. They're on one side. We're on the other. And then Hashem saves us. We
then finish our redemption. Yaakov to Israel- with a brief interlude fight with
Esau's angel and meeting with Esau's army, and the Jews with forty years in the
wilderness and lots of wars as well. The similarities are uncanny. They're
jumping out as us and it's where our sages saw that Yaakov sets the precedent for
all times for our return from Exile.
The question though perhaps in all cases, the Baal Ha'Tanya
and Shem Mi'Shmuel note is why do we always have to escape and leave like that.
I mean in Yaakov's case, Hashem told him that he should return home. He was
established. He could've just picked up and told Lavan, hey, the parties over.
Thanks for the stuff… But I'm going home now. Why run? Why escape in the middle
of the night like a refugee? Why even give Lavan an opening to say, that we
stole from him, that we're running away and hiding and leaving like an illegal
criminal. Why not be upfront? What's there to be afraid of? Isn't this what Hashem
told him to do?
As well, I mean Yaakov had to know Lavan would come chasing
after him. That ultimately this guy wasn't going to so easily let his prize
bread-winner leave. They would eventually have to confront one another. So
what's the point of leaving like that? It's just delaying the inevitable.
That's even more true in the case of Egypt. On the one
hand, Egypt is paralyzed. They told us we could leave. The y gave us their
stuff. Hashem pretty much scared the "bee-yoshka" and every
other idolatry out of them… So why does it say we ran away? Why did we just
grab our matzos and run to catch the first flight out. As well, we probably
guessed that they would be coming after us as well as Pharaoh as well like some
Presidents we know have a habit of changing their mind every other day. And he
certainly wasn't going to let his prize horse and chariots run just check out
like that. So why the running? Why couldn't we just get up and tell them we're
gonna take a few days to pack. You better not come after us. Why didn't Hashem
just finish the job there. Why does He want us to run? To escape. To flee. To
get freaked out. And then swoop in to save us. It seems that the answer is because
an essential part of our leaving, and Yaakov's leaving is the flee-and-escape-model
playbook.
What our Rebbes tell us is that the fleeing of Yaakov and
of Egypt have to happen in order to ingrain in our Jewish DNA the strength and
power to run away and escape from country to country in our exile. It's not
easy. We can see the signs. We can see the posts. We can feel the decrees and the
tides are turning. We can even hear Hashem calling and commanding us to come
home. Yet, ultimately that pull that our comfort level and even discomfort
level of feeling home in our adopted country will be too strong for us to ever
leave. We need to act before it's too late. We need to leave even though we
know that there might be war and consequences in front of us. We need to
realize that hoping for a diplomatic solution, for a strong conversation about
the rising anti-Semitism, that both Yaakov and the Jews in Egypt faced with the
powers that be…is not going to lead to anything fruitful. It just leads to
Dachau. To Treblinka. To not making it to Yerushalayim and home to our father
Avraham and Yitzchak.
Yes, they might and will be ticked off if we all leave at
once. If we leave in the middle of the night and run away. They might hate us
more. They might come back after us. They might and will chase us. But that's
not our problem. That's Hashem's. For ourselves though. We need to feel and
realize that we have to just flee- even when we don't feel we need to flee. Or
perhaps even before we need to escape. Because if we don't ultimately, we will
just get sucked back in again. We'll neve leave. And there's a limit to how
many miracles Hashem will preform to protect us in order that we stay there. Because
He wants us home already. He wants to come home Himself.
Are we at the end of our galus? What do you think? Do you
feel like Yaakov did, that the face of the sons of Lavan are not what they were
before? Do you believe like the Jews in Egypt that things might change now that
Pharaoh was taught a lesson? That we can hang out a bit longer. That we can
wait until our shmura matzos rise a bit more. That' leaving now will not
really accomplish anything, as they will come after us. It's dangerous over there
as well. I'm not telling you what to think. I'm just asking you, whatever you
do think, or whenever you feel it might come… Don't you think it's worth having
a plan? Ma'aseh Avos Siman La'banim… how will your story end?
Have an escapeful Shabbos,
Rabbi Ephraim Schwartz
************************
YIDDISH PROVERB OF THE WEEK
“Az men
antloift fun feier, bagegent men dos vasser.." -
When you flee from fire, you run into water.
RABBI SCHWARTZ'S TOUR GUIDE EXAM QUESTION OF THE WEEK
answer below at end of Email
24. “The
Peutinger Map” is an ancient road map from the ______ period.
In Islam, what
is a Surah?
A. An Islamic
legal ruling
B. The
biography of the Prophet
C. A chapter
in the Quran
D. The Friday
sermon in the mosque
RABBI SCHWARTZ’S COOL VIDEO OF THE WEEK
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wg3obrr6Rng
– The latest Bardak! Back again
Surprise wedding…
https://soundcloud.com/ephraim-schwartz/vzakeynu-lirot-banim – In honor of the birth of all of the
tribes in the parsha this is my V'zakeinu song I composed for my first
grandson. YItz Berry arrangements amazing the perfect Shalom Zachor song…
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qC4Jf1txd3g&list=RDqC4Jf1txd3g&start_radio=1 – V'nhiney Hashem Mutzav Alav- Moshe Asulander
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5FoDIJbAIuc
– Ma Norah Ha'Makom the one and
only Chaim Dovid!
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9_6YezOLkdw&list=RD9_6YezOLkdw&start_radio=1
– Heaven Knows my Name- Waterbury Parent visiting day.. I found this inspiring…
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=a-atYl3qRJk
– Love this song about Yaakov's dream from Sruly Lipshutz Vayachaloim
RABBI SCHWARTZ'S ERA’S AND THEIR
PLACES AND PEOPLE IN ISRAEL OF THE WEEK
The Oral Tradition - 3427 from Creation-333 BC – Perhaps the greatest and most last accomplishment of the Men
of the Great Assembly was the formation of the law and Torah into what is
called the Mishna. The Mishna, which is the formalized order of
the Oral Tradition that had been received and passed down from Sinai
and from the judges and prophets from the First Temple period and
our exile in Bavel, was eventually written down- in violation of a Torah
Commandment, centuries later by Rebbi Yehuda Ha'Nasi. Yet, it first is
established by these Great men of the Assembly.
See, until that time there were
prophets and leaders that would constantly be available to answer questions
about the law. For the written Torah that we have is merely the blueprints for
the laws. It isn't written to be specific. The Torah itself makes that very
clear when it tells us that we are obligated to eat an animal that is ritually
slaughtered "as I have commanded you". Yet in the entire book it
doesn't tell us what that process is. As well the Torah is quite clear that we
can be stoned to death for violating the Shabbos by doing "work". Yet
it doesn't tell us what that means exactly On Sukkot we're told that we
have a mitzva to take a nice fruit- yet what that fruit is, and frankly I don't
think an Etrog would've been my first choice. So, it's clear that there was
an oral tradition that they received on Sinai and after that
elaborated and explained these details.
Yet, unlike the written Torah,
there is a prohibition to write down the Oral tradition. It was laws
that were meant to be passed down from Rabbi to student, from father to son,
from mother to daughter. The genius of the Torah is that it was never meant to
be a book that you can just hand to someone and say read and then come back to
me and you'll know what to do. There was always a tradition that needed to be
passed down. Someone had to always have to have someone to look back at and
realize that they were a link in a chain that dates back to Sinai. One
always had to have someone to look back to, to guide him, to direct and inspire
him. Judaism is not a legal framework, it's a community, it's long line of
revelation and thus it was transmitted from father to son and teacher to
student until this return to Israel of Ezra and Nechemia.
As we noted that in this return
the majority of the Rabbis and scholars remained in Bavel. We would have
for the first time a broken nation living in two different countries. Israel's
new commonwealth wouldn't have the Torah leaders and tradition of the
majority that remained in Exile. Yet, Torah itself was only meant and able to
be formulated in Sinai. Thus the Ezra and the Rabbis recognized that
there was a need to formalize the traditions and laws that they had received into
a formal easy memoizable format. It was of course not written down. That was
prohibited. But it was developed into a system that would be taught and passed
down. And thus the concept of the Mishna was born.
They took the laws and divided it
into 6 orders. The laws of Agriculture- Zeraim, the laws of the
special designated holidays and Shabbos- Moed, the laws relating
to Marriage- Nashim, the civil laws of commerce and monetary
laws- Nezikim, the laws of the Temple- Kodshim and
The laws of purity- Taharot. This framework is what ultimately Rabbi
Yehuda Ha'Nasi ultimately formulated into the written work of Mishna
in the second century after the destruction of the Temple.
Until that point for centuries
there were not even debates it was a clearly passed down tradition. It was only
with time that confusion began. There were arguments about the law and its
source derivations. And thus, Rebbi understanding that the period of
exile and dispersion was once again upon us took this Mishna concept and
violated the law in order to save it. Yet even in his written Mishna he
left it in a way that would still require a teacher and transmitter to understand
and clarify the practical aspects of how to observe the Torah.
That Mishna ultimately
evolved into the Talmud. Which led to the Rambam, the Shulchan Aruch, the
Mishna Berura and every Jewish lawbook since then. On the one hand it preserves
Judaism and it's laws and it's practices. Yet at the same time, sadly and tragically
it also turned us into a people of the Book, where we can feel we are doing
what we need to and following the laws as good citizens anywhere in the world, and
even feeling spiritually fulfilled, but it has distanced us from the need to
come back to Israel bring down the Shechina and build the Bais Ha'Mikdash.
Because we have Toirah… We have the book. We've forgotten that it's just
meant to be a blueprint and roadmap back to the Sinai experience. Back to Yerushalayim.
We've forgotten that this was temporary measure and violation of the law,
because the scholars and Rabbis didn't come back to rebuild the Temple and live
that life here. Hopefully, it is a sin we can still rectify today.
RABBI SCHWARTZ'S
TERRIBLLY ESCAPE JOKES OF THE WEEK
You know how I escaped from Iraq? Iran
How many men escaped the destruction of Sodom?
A Lot.
Johnny had been in prison for only a year into
his life long sentence with no hope for parole that he had decided that he
would not be dying in prison. Using outside connections and some small favors
he was able to get a small spoon and a local map of the surrounding area to the
prison. After ten years of carefully digging his tunnel without getting caught,
he had finally dug all the way to just under a warehouse a few blocks away from
the prison. Breaking through the surface he and being blinded by sunlight.
After his eyes had adjusted he stuck his head out of the hole to survey the
area. He noticed that his calculations were off and he had dug all the way
through a sandbox in a playground next to a little girl who was playing in it.
Without a care in the world he proceeded to
jump out of the hole and hoisting the little girl up into the air he shouted
"I'm free, I'm free, I'm free!!!"
After setting the girl on the ground she told
him "that's nothing I'm four."
.A redhead, a blonde and a brunette escape
from jail and hide in a barn. The police close in, so the three women each hide
in a sack. The police search the barn, and to check each sack, a police officer
kicks it as he walks past.
The officer kicks the redhead’s sack, and the
redhead says, “Meow!”
The officer kicks the brunette’s sack, and the
brunette says, “Woof, woof.” The officer kicks the blonde’s sack, and
the blonde shouts, “Potatoes!.
What did the math teacher say when the parrot
escaped? Polygon
A Muhammed Hamas terrorist, a Ibrahim a
Palestinian, and a Achmed the Iranian escape a burning building by climbing to
the roof. The Israeli Firemen are on the street below, holding a blanket for
them to jump in.
The firemen yell to the Muhammed, "Jump!
Jump! It's your only chance to survive!"
The Muhammed jumps and SWISH! The firemen yank
the blanket away... the Muhammed slams into the sidewalk like a matbucha plate.
"C'mon! Jump! You gotta jump!' say
the firemen to the Redhead.
"Oh...no! You're gonna pull the
blanket away!" says the Redhead.
"No! It's Hamas we can't stand! We're
OK with Palestinians!"
"OK," says the Ibrahim, and he
jumps. SWISH!
The firemen yank the blanket away, and the Arab
is flattened on the pavement like a pita.
Finally, the Achmed steps to the edge of the
roof. Again, the firemen yell, "Jump! You have to jump!"
"Oh no! You're gonna pull the blanket
away!" says the Achmed.
"No! Really! You have to jump! We won't
pull the blanket away!"
"Not until you put the blanket down
and back away!" yelled the Achmed.
A monkey escaped from the petting zoo.He rode
out the gates on the back of a baby sheep.
Authorities have stated that he is on the
lamb.
Two prisoners have
escaped today. One is 7 feet, the other is 3 ft 6 in. Police are looking high
and low for them.
What do you call a
dwarf psychic who escaped from prison? A small medium at large.
Where did the hackers
go when they escaped? No idea, they just ransomware
*************************************************
The answer to this week”s question is C – Whewww… this is really getting annoying! I can't seem to get off this half right half wrong streak I'm stuck in. The second part was easy. I knew Surah. It's an easy word for their pesukim or chapter in the Koran. I hear it mentioned when people quote the Koran showing what an anti-semitic and pretty much anti-non muslim book it is. On the other hand I got the first part way wrong… although for a second I did think it might be the Crusader period, which was in fact the correct answer. I wimped out and answered Ottoman and was wrong. See, I guess I gotta go with my first instincts sometimes So half right and half wrong AGAIN! makes the new score Rabbi Schwartz having 16 points and the MOT having 6 points on this latest Ministry of Tourism exam.