from the
Holy Land
from
Rabbi Ephraim Schwartz
"Your friend in Karmiel"
November 13th 2026 -Volume 17 Issue 6 3rd of Kisleiv 5787
Parshat Toldos
Click here below for print edition
(Weekly Newsletter - Parshat Toldos 2026 )
On the other hand, there are others that think this is not such a good thing. Like me, they understand that the money we get from America really doesn't and will not change anything about Israel's foreign policy or how we will act or respond or defend ourselves- or perhaps more accurately and pathetically not defend ourselves and act. It doesn't make a difference how much money we get or don't get from America, or how "independent" we believe we are; we're not really going to go in and wipe out our enemies, conquer our biblical homeland- which of course includes major parts of Jordan, Syria, Lebanon, Egypt and even Iraq, forget about Gaza and the West Bank. We're not going to stop providing "humanitarian" aid, to the animals that are sworn to destroy us. We won't even stop giving them weapons to kill us with.
Financial independence won't do anything more to inspire us to act and respond and doing what we need to do, than hundreds of dead babies, burnt women, kidnapped citizens and murdered soldiers. It won't give us the strength and fortitude, to fulfill our Divinely given mandate and to realize that no other country in the world would tolerate and allow or has ever allowed such and enemy to grow in their midst… Ok except for maybe the entire Europe and now the United States as well… lately. But certainly not historically and any country that still has a brain on its head.
So the only thing we're out on in this deal and that will change is that we lose out on the money. That's not a good thing. As well, it's a sign of the increasing anti-Israel/Semitism (same thing…) in America that Trump is obviously responding to. It's a biblical fulfillment of bringing us closer and closer to the day and moment that the Torah and prophets tell us when we will truly understand that we're alone. am levadad yishkon- a nation without any world support. Without any US Benjamins helping us out. They're the last hold-outs for us to finally get it. And Baruch Hashem, after the last elections in America, I think we're getting closer and closer to that beautiful promised day, when as Shlomo Carlebach, so beautifully sang…
"Israel has no friends in the world….
The holy land, the holy people of Israel are all alone…
An am levadad yishkon…
But you know what we have….?"
Ok, you know the rest of it. You're humming it already… If you don't watch the video below.
Now, I happen to have a bit of a different take on this whole thing. I usually do. It's why you come here weekly. And as usual. It's not just my dei'ah, strong personal opinion. It's Daas Torah. It's this week's Parsha. It's eye-opening. It turns everything on its head. It's where I and you should always turn to, if you want to understand what's going on really in the world. What our view should be, and where this whole ride is taking us. It's kind of the reason, why Hashem gave us the Book. It's why we're meant to learn it every week. And why it's eternal. It's for us today.
But before we get to the speech/letter that I think needs to be sent to Trump or perhaps even made at the UN from the State of Israel, let's take a look at the last few parshiyot and perhaps even more fundamentally at the lives of our Patriarchs and what Hashem counterintuitively wants from them and from us. What I think becomes pretty much very obvious is that our and their jobs on this world is not to sit quietly and study Torah and "serve Him" in our own very quiet personal way in our ghettos and Bais Medrash. It's not and has never been about our own "personal" growth. It starts with the first statement/revelation to Avraham Avinu back in Lech Lecha, where Hashem tells him to leave all of the Torah community that he built for decades behind and head off to the lowest and most impure place on the world in Canaan. Yet, even upon arriving there Avraham is quickly sent down to Egypt, more impurity, a perhaps even lower place. It's clear Hashem doesn't want him to stay in Lakewood.
The stories and orders continue. He's meant to fight with Gaza and Avimelech. He has to go wage war against Nimrod and most of the world. He's digging wells right and left and continuously having his rights challenged. He has to deal with Sodom. With Yishmael. He has to take his son up to a mountain and almost slaughter him and then deal with Benei Cheit to get a burial ground. That's not a life of Torah and personal growth and Kollel study.
The same is true for Yitzchak as we see in this week's parsha. Same thing. Gaza. Plishtim wells. Kidnapped wives. Fights. Standing up for himself. And then of course continuous anguish about his psychopathic son Esau who is clearly going off the derech. The plan of Hashem for them and for us- as we're told ma'aseh avos siman la'banim- the actions of our Patriarchs are meant to be our signs for what we are meant to undergo, accomplish and what our mission is, is clearly not about finding a nice corner in the Bais Medrash and keeping our head down and learning and praying.
Finally, this week, is when it all comes to a head. We have Yaakov and Esau. They are born, both Jewish by the way… to Jewish parents- unlike Yishmael. They would seem to have divergent roles, we are told. It's a nice plan. Yaakov sits in Kollel, while Esau joins the IDF. The Torah is kept pristine and pure and holy. While Esau does the dirty work of eradicating evil, hunting, killing, conquering and supporting his brother in Torah. It's a good plan. It may actually work one day. But first we have to fix a few problems with it.
See, in that plan, Yaakov was meant to be the first born. He needs to lead his brother Esau. He needs to be the connector. The guide. The leader. Esau though, ever the aggressor, pushes out first. He's anxious to get out there and destroy those avoda zara houses every time his mother passes them. I mean imaginably he wasn't pushing to worship there, while he was in his mother's womb and before he had a yetzer hara… (like how I did that there…😊).
Yet he needs guidance and he needs direction. He needs someone with the Torah view of Yaakov to teach him, lead him, guide him in order that the function of Creation which is that the entire world will recognize Hashem will come to actuality. But Esau, jumps the gun. Figuratively and literally. Yaakov is born second. He goes quietly into his tent and makes a little ghetto for himself. The world is not his problem. He just needs Torah Torah Torah. Learning is geshmak. I feel close to Hashem. The world is a scary place. There are smartphones out there. And war and money and college can all make me go off the derech. Better stay in my tent.
But Hashem has a different plan. See, it's not about your personal growth, Yaakov. It's about Me. It's about the world. It's about getting Esau to where he needs to get to. You need to have the blessing and mandate of being…. Get this straight. The gevir l'achecha- you Yaakov are the master of your brother. Nations need to bow down to you. The worlds regimes need to bow to you. The children of your mother- Esau, the world, all his descendants. Rome, Russia, America Europe- all need to bow down to you. The ones that curse you will be cursed and the ones that bless you will be blessed. This is the blessing of Yitzchak to Yaakov. This is the blessing of Avraham that he passes down to him.
When Esau comes crying afterwards for the blessing, like a little baby, Yitzchak tells him that its too late. He is a slave. Yaakov is his master. Not just his master but all he owns belongs to Yaakov. Even when he gives him a bit of a consolation blessing afterwards it is tempered by the fact he still and will always remain his slave. His only respite will be when Yaakov doesn't follow the Torah, he can remove the yoke a bit and loosen his collar. But America works for us. We don't work for them.
How does that make you feel? Have you ever even imagined a world like that? Do you look at yourself as the master of the world? It's funny we have and always had a tendency to look at other Jews as being their masters. As better than them. As being the ones that need to share with them the light of the only true way to serve Hashem-which is of course the way that we are doing it.
If you're frum it means by studying torah and wearing a black hat and staying in Kollel. If you're Chasidish its by going to the Mikva a lot spending a lot davening and chasidus. If you're Chabad it's shlichus, if your Breslav its Uman and dancing and tikkun klali. If your dati it's serving in the army, and saying prayer for the state and conquering the land. If you're Modox it's Torah and Derech Eretz and becoming a respectable Shomer Shabbat Jew who is involved in the world and goes to Pesach programs. If your conservative or reform it's tikkun olam and pro-Palestine. We all are masters of our own fellow Jews, they're all second-class slaves to us that need to follow our lead. Because I'm the only one that knows and understand what Hashem truly wants. The only thing we all have in common is that we all agree it's a mitzva d'oryasa to vote….
Yet, as well, I don't believe or see any of us having or taking that same sense of righteous indignation and sense of purpose and meaning and directing it or even stating it to the world. When it comes to the rest of the world, we hide and crawl back in our tent. We don't want to be that face. We don't feel we have the power influence or even divine mandate to get up and tell that to the world. That they are meant to serve us. That we are the lords. That their job is to mamash mamash bow down to us. That's not our place. Those are the clothing of Esau.
We're not comfortable lording over Esau. We were born second. We forgot that we were supposed to born first. We forgot that he sold us the birthright. That there was one moment in time when he came home and we realized that if we didn't buy it from him, Hashem's presence would never be revealed in the world. It was that day when Avraham died and all that Esau could think about was his hunger and his personal "growth" at least in his belly and not the hole left in the world of someone that would be the Avraham of the world. That would bring that message of Hashem and His light to the world. That was the moment, when we left the tent. When we poured the chulent down his throat. When we told him, that he only eats when we tell him to. That we are truly the first-born and it's time for him to get into line.
There was a time when I was asked to speak to Kollel Rabbis that were entering the Jewish outreach/kiruv world. They had asked me to speak to them about some of the challenges of this type of work and to give them tips and direction of some of the essential things that I had learned from my years of experience that would assist them in their tasks and understanding of their mission. I chose to speak about the idea of fundraising. I felt that it's an uncomfortable topic. Guys want to go out and teach Torah. They want to inspire and impress with their wisdom, with their warmth, with their love and with their brilliant proofs and joy of yiddishkeit, which are all certainly important, yet not always entirely effective. Fundraising- asking people, particularly your students, for money, isn't geshmak. It cheapens you. It makes you all about money. It's a business. It's about reaching into their pockets. It makes me a shnorrer- not a rabbi and teacher.
My feeling was just the opposite. I told them that in my experience I found that all the classes and Shabbos meals in the world didn't accomplish as much in the personal growth of someone as one nice check from them did. If they're not investing and partnering and joining the initiative than at the end of the day… they're really not in. They're not going to move much. Yet, the second they wrote their first personal nice check. The first time they made a commitment to become a partner on a regular basis. That they weren't just your student but started a partner with you in your mission. All of a sudden very fast they begin to change. They grow. They really, really get it.
Now it's not easy to make that ask for many. I can get them to put on tefillin, to keep Shabbos, to eat kosher, to even keep the laws of family purity. But money? For a sizeable donation. For a building campaign. That’s personal. That's money. That's not spiritual. That's reaching into their pockets. That makes me a shnorrers. Yet, I would tell them that first of all tzedaka is a mitzva like very mitzva is and there should be no compunction about teaching them about that mitzva as any other mitzva, as sukkah, lulav and matza on Pesach and bentching after they ate. But on a deeper level, what I believe bothers us is that we don't believe enough that their giving money is really giving them the greatest merit ever. It's donating to the Bais Ha'Mikdash. It's spreading the light of Hashem to the entire world. It's the deal of a lifetime. It's bringing them the ultimate goodness, greatness and opportunity that they've ever been offered. It's giving them life. It's partnering them with Hakadosh Baruch Hu's mission for this world.
Yet, it's hard for only reason. Because we don't really believe it enough. We don't believe in our mission. We don't believe that we can do it. That they can do it. We see dollars and credit cards and we don't see bricks of the Bais Ha'Mikdash. We see our small little outreach centers and we don't see the sacrifices on the altar in Yerushalayim and Shechina descending and resting amongst us and shining out the light to the world. We see our own personal spiritual growth. We see the small little mitzvos that we can get them to do. We see the pages of Talmud and machshava and Mussar that we can teach and learn. But we don't see the big picture. We don't really get what our real agenda needs to be and why we were chosen for this job. What' we're really here for and what we are meant to accomplish. Because if we did, we'd have no problem doing what we're meant to. And this is not only true for our fellow unaffiliated Jews it's the message the State of Israel and the Jewish people are meant to give to the world.
It is with that understanding of our role and the way to bring Mashiach and to fulfill our mandate here in Israel and in the entire world that the response and letter that Israel needs to send to the world needs to be as follows.
"Dear Mr. Trump and esteemed slaves and servants of the United Nations,
"It has come to our attention that there has been discussion about your withholding and canceling your loan guarantees, grants and financial interests with our country. Unfortunately for you, and perhaps eventually fortunately as well this is unacceptable to us. See, because we here in Israel our your masters. All that you own and perceive to control and have earned in America and Europe belong to us. These are not loan guarantees that we are seeking or tarrifs even. They are tribute that we feel that you need to pay to us in order that we can have what require to finish the job that Hashem chose us for to rebuild His Temple and eradicate evil from the world. "
"We are brothers, Edom. Yishmael is destroying your country and evil is coming in your midst. Our father Yitzchak gave the two of us a job. You chose to abdicate the role to us to be at the forefront of this battle. To be your light. To show and teach you what the function of creation is all about and how we can make the world a better place. We study Torah, we have maintained a tradition and that wisdom from our shared grandfather Avraham. Yet as well, we have taken on your role of conquering and settling the land of Israel and begun the process of revealing Hashem.
We did this in the past, but we lost our way. We didn't guide you. We followed your orders and as Yitzchak told you, when we don't lead and we follow you, then you will throw off that burden and you burned down that house. You killed us throughout the generations because we were always to small-minded and reclusive to take the role that Yitzchak blessed us with. The job Hashem chose us for, when He called us Yisrael. "
"But that ends here and now. Please send your tribute, your dollars and your Euros to us immediately. Please include some of those new cool nuclear weapons and tanks and subs you've made as well, so they can be put to good use. This is your privilege. These are your orders. Mr. Trump, our dear brother. You can stop bowing now. You can take our hand and lead with us. Together we will make a great time. You will eradicate that evil you've been wanting to since our mother's womb and we will shed the light and build the Temple for all nations. We look forward to greeting you here with all the other nations."
TYFYATTM (thank you for your attention to this matter,
Your brother,
Yaakov/ Yisrael
Have a superior Shabbos,
Rabbi Ephraim Schwartz
************************
YIDDISH PROVERB OF THE WEEK
“Der emess iz a kricher." - Truth is a slowpoke..
RABBI SCHWARTZ'S TOUR GUIDE EXAM QUESTION OF THE WEEK
answer below at end of Email
23. The country to which Israel supplies freshwater is __________
Which of the following statements regarding the Mediterranean climate in Israel is correct?
A. Most of Israel's land area is within this climatic region.
B. Most of central and northern Israel is in this climatic region.
C. Israel is the southernmost region on Earth where this climate prevails.
D. Only Mount Hermon and the northern Golan Heights are within this climatic region in Israel.
RABBI SCHWARTZ’S COOL VIDEO OF THE WEEK
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JjsGOPzzRfE&list=RDJjsGOPzzRfE&start_radio=1 – Reb Shlomo Carlebach… perhaps most famous piece and song…. Yisrael Betach Ba'Hashem
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ic3tbYNHgVc&list=RDIc3tbYNHgVc&start_radio=1 - A new Shwekey Doni Gross- a Shabbos release… Ata Kidashta…
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fWj6c4Fn-Ig&list=RDfWj6c4Fn-Ig&start_radio=1 – Avraham Fried and Ari Stern- Hatov Va'Hameitiv… Interesting vibe…
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QUFyBcDZPuA&list=RDQUFyBcDZPuA&start_radio=1 – Shmueli Ungar… one of my favorite songs of his… Yitein Lecha from this week's blessing…
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MfuewamW2hs&list=RDMfuewamW2hs&start_radio=1 –Ari Goldwags's latest release Run Run Slow Down…
RABBI SCHWARTZ'S ERA’S AND THEIR PLACES AND PEOPLE IN ISRAEL OF THE WEEK
Knesset Changes and Laws- 3427 from Creation-333 BC – So as we noted with the sealing of the books of the prophets the Men of the Great Asssembly established a new commonwealth with some important laws and changes that transformed the face of Judaism until today.
The first obviously immediate need was of course the work in the Temple and shifts of the Kohanim that would represent the nation before Hashem. In the first Temple there were 24 different Mishmarot that served in the first Temple, yet only four of them returned with the men return of the Jews from Bavel. The rest preferred life in Bavel Park and Ga-lakewood… So they took those four families and divided them up into 24 families. As well they established what we call the Nusach Hetfilla- the order of prayers the 18 we recite of Shemona Esrei.
Now although they had the Temple and service it seemed to be a need, according to Maimonides to have this as the Jews were in Exile to remain connected to Hashem. Seemingly the Talmud tells us that this was eventually forgotten as it would seem that when the Temple was in Israel, and daily sacrifices were offered on behalf of the nation that wasn't commonly done. At least in Eretz Yisrael. It was only after the destruction of the Temple that it was reestablished.
The big changes though that did take hold were in all areas of Jewish law. They established the laws of shiva and mourning, they established the laws on carrying within the 2000 amos of Shabbos. Bedikas Chametz on Pesach, secondary forbidden marital relations, the prohibition to drink wine handled by non-Jews, the marital document of Kesuva for women, The laws of tithes on all fruits and vegetables besides the 7 speices of Israel, various laws of family purity and mikva, working on chol hamoed and the laws of muktza… and more and more and more…
I think we take much of this for granted as being basic Judaism, but this is a revolution in the nation. There probably has never been such a change since the Torah was given on Sinai until today that so effected the way we relate to and observe Judaism. There were some of these that were established beforehand, yet their period is the conclusion of this change. From that time on there would be no new decrees that were accepted by the nation that have the status of a Rabbinic prohibition.
Their last and final big accomplishment was establishing the concept of the Mishna and oral tradition which would not be codified for centuries but the period and era of this transmission being codified and ordered starts with them as well. We'll talk more about that next week.
RABBI SCHWARTZ'S TERRIBLLY RACIST SLAVERY JOKES OF THE WEEK
Slavery is such an ugly word...I prefer the term lifetime unpaid internship.
Where do dungeon masters keep their slaves? In debasement.
After a stressful day, Bob comes home and sits in his backyard, drinking a beer. As he's getting up to get a snack, he stops and asks, "Jesus, what is the meaning of life?"
To which Jesus replies, "You slave in the sun to support the ones you love. You make money so you can buy things for your family to keep them happy."
The man asks,"Jesus, why is life so hard?"
To which Jesus replies,"That, no one may ever know. You have to overcome many obstacles to be successful."
The man asks again,"How was the universe created?"
Jesus replies,"I'm sorry, señor, but can you stop asking questions? I'm trying to mow your lawn."
What's the difference between a cow and slavery? You can't milk a cow for 200 years.
Do all black people have a problem with slavery? Or just mine
An ethnically diverse group of people are doing something…
An African-American, a Mexican-American, Jewish-American, and a white man are walking along the beach in Florida. One of them stumbles over a lamp and as he picks it up, a genie appears. The genie thanks them from freeing him from the lamp and offers them each a wish.
The African-American says, "My native land has suffered from all the people stolen away by slavery. I wish for all my people to be returned to Africa to start a new age of African success." As he finishes speaking, poof, he is gone.
The Mexican-American is inspired and says, "My native land has suffered from all the people run out by the cartels and corruption. I wish for all my people to be returned to Mexico to start a new age of Mexican success." As he finishes speaking, poof, he is gone.
The Jewish-American feels the same way and says, "My native land has had my people chased out for thousands of years. I wish for all my people to be returned to Israel to start a new age of Israeli success." As he finishes speaking, poof, he is gone.
The white guy is clearly taken aback with all that has happened. He says, "Let me get this straight, all the black, mexicans, and jews are gone? Lemme get a diet coke."
I was teaching a bunch of black teenagers about slavery. None of them liked the concept, but their grandparents were sold on the idea..
What did the slave owner said to his slave during the gold rush? I wanna make you mine.
A slave is working out on the cotton plantation one hot day and the master approached him. "Say, Toby, I'm gonna use the outhouse, so I expect to see at least another barrel filled with cotton befo' I get back,"the master said.
"Yessuh, massa," Toby replied.
So the master went to the outhouse and as he sat down a copperhead come up and bite him in the behind. The master yelled like a banshee. The yell alarmed Toby, who ran to the outhouse to see the master writhing in pain with his behind in the air.
"Boy!!,"the master said. "A copperhead just bit me right on my backside. Toby, you better run down to the doctor and ask him what to do about a snake bite."
"Yessuh, massa," Toby replied.
Toby made it to the doctor and knocked on the door.
"Toby, boy? What are you doing?" the doctor said.
"My massa been bit by a copperhead! What do I got to do to keep him alive?" Toby blurted.
"Ok Ok," the doctor said calmly. "First, you have to clean the wound. Then, you have to suck the poison out. I don't have tools here, but you can do it with your lips. So clean the wound then, suck the poison out. OK?"
The doctor closed the door and Toby ran back to his master.
"Well Toby? What the doctor say?," the master said.
With a smirk Toby answered, "He said...you dead."
A woman converting to Islam is like a black person converting to slavery.
*************************************************
The answer to this week”s question is B – I feel repetitive here but one again it seems that I can't get off of this 50/50 streak here. The first part over here I got correct. The answer is Jordan which is one of the driest countries in the world. They literally have water for only a few hours a day over there in some places. And they have to store it all. We provide them with billions of cubes of water because they're our friends… right? OK not so much… Because we're idiots. But anyways it's a big tumult lately because as they continue to curse us out. Israel has been threatening to cut them off. The second part though I got wrong. I was really debating back and forth between B& C. I thought the Mediteranean climate was certainly in North and Central. But I thought the Golan and Hermon and entire Jordan Valley area wasn't really the most of the North. So I went with C that it's the lowest in the world, although I suspected that Egypy might've been more South. The truth is I was wrong on that too, as Chile and Argentina are even more south. I didn't even chap or think of them. So half right and half wrong makes the new score Rabbi Schwartz having 15.5 points and the MOT having 5.5 points on this latest Ministry of Tourism exam.