Karmiel

Karmiel
Our view of the Galile
Showing posts with label living Israel. Show all posts
Showing posts with label living Israel. Show all posts

Friday, May 8, 2026

Money for Nothing- Parshat Behar Bechukosai 2026 5786

 Insights and Inspiration

from the

Holy Land

from

Rabbi Ephraim Schwartz

"Your friend in Karmiel"

May 8th 2026 -Volume 16 Issue 28 21st of Iyar 5786

 

Parshat Behar- Bechukosai

 Money for Nothing

 

It's been rough for us tour guides here. It's been a while since we've seen any of you. I don't think even in Corona, or the beginning of this war have I ever gone this long without touring one of you. Not Pesach. Not Lag Ba'Omer. My summer is still pretty much wide open. Some people refer to a downturn in their business. "It's been slow, lately", others say, when they don't want to really talk about how bad it really is. But I'm here to tell you the real scoop, in case you didn't get it. It's dead. It's almost three months now. It's from before Purim. It's like the Jews in the wilderness and the manna is running out, there's no water and there's just a big hot dry dead wilderness in front of us. I get their kvetching a bit more, these days. I can understand why Hashem got upset at Moshe for being so harsh with us about our lack of faith, at least at one point. It ain't easy.


There are quite a few guys that are doing alternate things. Sruli, started to do some Real Estate. Avi and Ari are doing some driving and deliveries. Some of my driver friends got gigs doing army deliveries. Even my friend who bought an ATV business before this whole thing started is now renting them out to the Army. He figures if they can't be used to share the beauty and nature of Eretz Yisrael with people that are coming here to visit, then at least they should be put to good use killing the mamzers that made this happen and perhaps even potentially, hopefully expanding the current borders of Israel to those more in line with our biblical promise. Creating new routes and trails to take people on, when this is all over.

My friend Yoni, has been on my case to join him on these Auschwitz, Europe, graves, old shuls and dead murdered massacred Jews gig he's got going on. As if there's not enough of that to see over here… It's always interested me, that there are people that want to see that stuff. That are not scared of heading out to countries where they killed all of our ancestors, where they would do it again, where there's no Israeli army that would even pretend to be interested in saving you. Why spend money and help an economy that would use that money to give parnassah to the grandchildren of the same people that helped the Nazi's and even sold your grandparents out to them? Why aren't you nervous about going to a place where anti-Semitism and Jew-killing is a favorite national pastime?


Yeah, I know, you've got that going on in the States as well, these days, so maybe it doesn't make you so nervous. You're used to burying your head in the sand. Which is usually good practice historically for when they make you dig your own graves. Ouch! But what possible inspiration does one get out of those places in Europe? What do people find or see there besides, death, blood, and tumah? And don't tell me that it's to learn the lessons of the past and "Never Again", because where are you still living…?


So I told him, no. I'm not interested. Don't get me wrong, I enjoy the occasional tour outside of Israel, as my Swiss and Africa trips reveal. But I don't want to work there. I don't want to take Jews there. I don't want to connect them to those places. Hashem told us that we should never return to Egypt. After the expulsion from Spain, our sages as well declared that we should never go back there- of course they made an exception for 5 Star Pesach programs with separate swimming pools and spas, Mordechai Shapiro and Leiner singing, kosher magicians and poker tables, with big Rabbis who write columns about Mesora in Mishpacha magazine serving as Scholars in residence. But besides that our Rabbis felt that no one should step foot on that bloodied earth. I don't know why they didn't do that in Poland or the Ukraine, though. Maybe it's because the "Jewish travel" lobby would have to much to say. Maybe they didn't want to give up their future scholars in residence gigs. Maybe they just wanted to provide parnassa for tour guides during periods of time when Jews were too scared to come to Israel…


So what have I been up to? Well I filled you in on some of the stuff. My trips down South to Sinai to do some volunteering trimming grape vines in my friend Gal's field. I've started writing for Mishpacha magazine again. Stay tuned for the upcoming Shavuos edition. I'm just about finished with my new book, "War Torah", three years' worth of Parsha material and E-Mails seen through the eyes of a Rabbi/Tour Guide/ Oleh/ Me… which I hope to get out volume I, by the new Torah cycle. Sponsorship opportunities upcoming… Stay tuned! As well, I've been doing some more learning, reading and hitting the gym. Gotta keep the weight off, especially with all the couch sitting noshing, I've been doing.


What about Parnassa? It will come. That's what credit cards are for. As one of my tour guide friends, told me, after Corona, the first years of the war, and all the other gaps in business we've undergone, Hashem has always sent us our manna right back afterwards. It's gonna come. This past winter in fact, He even sent the parnassa beforehand. It was the busiest winter- at least until Purim since the post-Corona year. It's like the promise of getting triplicate in the 6th year before Shemitta, that this week's parsha tells us about. Hey, why should tour guides be different then Shemitta farmers in that regard. We both make our living off the land. We even bring them all our tourists. So, Hashem gave us the same advance He gives them, in the months before this latest tourism drought. I just wish he didn't have to crush the dollar in the process… But at least, I'm not earning any right now anyways, so I don’t feel so bad.


Well once we’re on the subject of havtachos from this week's parsha and the mitzva of Shemitta, the year that we take a Shabbos from working the land, and step back and say Hashem runs the world. He pays my bills. I'm sitting at His table and I don't have to worry about the next course. Let's see if this is only a farmer thing or not.


The mitzva that follows these laws is fascinatingly enough the laws of the prohibition to take interest. Seemingly this mitzva one would more appropriately expect to find in Mishpatim or in Devarim, as we do, rather than here in the middle of the mitzvos that have to do with Shemitta, Yovel and buying and selling land in Israel. The prohibition to take interest is applicable to every Jew everywhere. Even you guys outside of Israel. What's it got to do with what seems to be only Eretz Yisraeldikeh laws?


Now in case, you thought that this wasn't the case, the follow up verse and even more perplexing Rashi that explain them makes this even more clear. The reason the Torah tells us for this mitzva in Mishpatim is because he's your brother, you should worry about him, he will cry out to Hashem. As well, in Devarim it tells us that Hashem will give us bracha if we keep this mitzva. He will even bring us to the land to inherit it. It certainly seems that it has nothing to do with a specific connection to living in the land. Yet here, the pasuk tells us that we need to keep the mitzva because


 Vayikra (25:38) "I am Hashem, your God, who took you out of the Land of Egypt to give you the Land of Canaan to be Your God."


What does leaving Egypt have to do with charging interest? Rashi seems to address these questions, but his answers at first glance don't really seem to cut it.


Who took you out … " just as I discerned between a firstborn and a non-firstborn, I also recognize and will exact punishment from one who lends money to an Israelite on interest and claims that it belongs to a non-Jew.


Another explanation: “who took you out of Egypt” – I redeemed you on condition that you accept My commandments upon yourselves, even if they be difficult for you.


The problem with this Rashi's pshat is that first of all why is it the fact that Hashem is discerning between the first borns the barometer for Hashem's ability to tell the difference between one who lends with interest and doesn't. Hashem knows everything. He did ten plagues before that and showed he runs the world. He knows everyone's thoughts. The mitzva and prohibition seem to be directed to Jews who believe in Hashem. They're keeping the mitzvos. Perhaps they even believe in everything else. The challenge they may be forgetting and that this mitzva seems to be reminding us is that Hashem can tell who's a first born or not. What does this have to do with Ribbis?


As well, Rashi seems to learn this warning is directed not just to someone who charges interest, but rather someone who does it through a loophole. He gets a goy to lend it for him. He's trying to work the system. A way out of the mitzva. That's who this mitzva and warning is directed to. This is the mitzva that Rashi in the second pshat as well, seems to note is difficult. It's a different aspect of the mitzva then perhaps the other places where it discussed.

As well the next Rashis continue in what seems broader themes, but that the Torah seems to be noting is particularly note and warning worthy here.


To give you Canaan - as reward for accepting upon yourselves to fulfill My commandments.

The land of Canaan is given for many mitzvos. Perhaps even more so, for the mitzvos that can't be fulfilled here. The laws of the tithes, of sacrifices, of shemitta and yovel. What does interest have to do with living in the land. We can do that anywhere?


Yet it was the last Rashi that really threw me for a loop. Because it's not so much what he says, rather it's what he doesn't say. How he changes what is really said. And most of all the message and connection he seems to be making with our mitzva that sheds light on it all.

Rashi writes


In order to be a God to you - for whoever lives in the Land of Israel – I consider Myself his God, but


Before I finish this famous quote, that Rashi paraphrases here, I want to ask you how you believe it ends. If you're anyone that ever argued with anyone about making Aliya, on either side of the argument, you're bound to finish that sentence as Chazal do in Kesuvot and other places.


"He who lives outside of Israel is as if he has no God."


All good Aliyah snobs (as Rabbi Efrem G. coined the phrase recently) know this gemara and throw it at all of you guys all the time. It's the exact opposite and contrast to the one that lives in Israel. It makes sense. Yet that's not what Rashi quotes. It's not how he finishes off the quote. He changes it. He wants to make a different message here. The question is what.

Rashi ends off that phrase differently. He writes


"but whoever leaves I consider to be an idolater".


Who said anything about leaving Israel here? Why does leaving Israel have to do with lending with interest? As well, it seems that someone that leaves is even worse than the person that doesn't come. As here Rashi calls him an idolator. That's a lot harsher than the godless person that Chazal call he who doesn't live here at all. There's something going on here, and I believe it's an incredible message for tour guides without work in Israel today. That's obviously what Hashem wrote in the Torah to teach us. It's all about me.


Rashi, writes that whoever leaves the land of Israel is considered to be a idolator. It would seem that this refers not only to those who illegally pack out or abandon Israel. As the truth is there's not too many in their right mind that would actually leave when things are going good. As Reb Chayim Kanievsky once told someone that asked him about leaving because he got a better job offer there, that he's a halachic shoteh if he does so. He's patur from all mitzvos because he's a fool, or mentally challenged and isn't liable for his actions which have no meaning. Seemingly he sees him as someone who's given a diamond and throws it away. Rather Rashi says "whoever leaves". Even someone who has a good reason. Even someone who goes when it's permitted to leave. He falls into the category of one who is permitted to leave, whether it's for parnassa, for a shidduch or even to study Torah. He's also viewed by Hashem as an idolator. That's pretty harsh. But that's what Rashi paraphrases. That's what he seems to be saying is the connection to the mitzva of Ribbis over here.


Why would someone leave Israel? There's only one reason. The reason is because you don't believe that you can find all that you need here. That your parnassa can and will happen here. That your bashert is here. That your Torah will even be on a greater level here. That your kids won't go off the derech here. You believe in Hashem. You want to serve Him. You know he preforms miracles. That he's good for His word. That He's quite capable of providing us with Manna and water in the wilderness. That He can even bring ten plagues on Egypt. But you have trouble understanding that He can tell that you’re his first Born. You think that you're subject to the same hishtadlus that perhaps the rest of the non-first born world is.


Perhaps you believe that you're just a little bit better and more loved then the non-Jews. Enough so that you can't lend Jews money with interest. But you can still work the system through them. You can use the non-Jews and be like them to rip off your brother. To advance your business interests. You can lend money through them, but you're forgetting that you're sitting on the table of the King. That you're brother is a first-born. That all of the mitzvos Hashem has given us is for us to appreciate that we are at his table. He gave us the mitzva that wherever we are living we shouldn't lend with interest because if you do, then you're forgetting that He gave us the land. We have a bank where we are taken care of from where our savings come from.


If you lend with interest, you really don't believe in Eretz Yisrael either. You're worshipping the same idol that someone who leaves Israel is serving. You're serving the dollar. You're worse than someone who's never lived here and never experienced it, who's just a nebach godless tinok she'nishbu, that may even be wearing a black hat in Lakewood or a shtreimel in Boro Park. If you're here and you leave here because you think it's gonna be better there. That, only there is where your yeshuah, your parnassa, your Torah and your children's chinuch is, then you're inherently leaving Hashem to worship idols instead.


The farmers here who have kept shemitta, as the Torah promises them, have seen that blessing. My friend Gal, out in Sinai that I visited told me that the bracha was that he was able to take off and learn Torah in Yerushalayim for a year. The tens of thousands of Kollel families who somehow manage to marry off ten kids and buy them all apartments as well will tell you about the daily miracles they experience. The soldiers, the generals, the families and survivors of this war and the entire country that's lived through this war and seen those missiles flying over our head and the so many times we should've been wiped out, know that we're sitting on the King's Table upon which His eyes aren't removed for even one second.


We're not living b'keri- with the mikreh, the happenstance that those who are living outside in the godless world are living. Hashem doesn't have to put all other things aside to deal with reminding us of where we are, who we are. We can be yashevtem la'betach b'artzichem- we can live, settle, dwell, sleep and just live securely here in our land. It's the final and best bracha. It's the only place where we can do that. So, I'm not going anywhere these days. When are you going to join the party?


Have a Shabbos of Chizuk and Chazak!

Rabbi Ephraim Schwartz 

 

************************

YIDDISH PROVERB OF THE WEEK

 

" Di shversteh arbet iz arumtsugain laidik"– The hardest work is to go idle.

 

RABBI SCHWARTZ'S COOL VIDEO OF THE WEEK

 

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Zdfk4KAiad4   – Lubavitcher Rebbe gives chizuk to Reb Nochum Partzovitz of Mir… Wow…


https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cPI354InKqUTYH's latest new release and hit that's gonna hit all over until you get sick of it… Ahavas Yisrael- Yossi Green and Storch!


https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vDU4bEDI31Y   - Ronald Reagan's greatest aging Jokes


https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ATo6Pk1fAGQ – Kobi Brumer- New Bar Yochai Kodesh Hakedoshim- nice…!


https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Or3hlR093Qk – Dovi Lowy's Oseh Shalom unplugged… got into it this week…


RABBI SCHWARTZ'S TOUR GUIDE EXAM QUESTION OF THE WEEK

answer below at end of Email

 

31. A monument designed by the artist Dani Karavan near the city of Be'er Sheva is called

____________


The broad wall in Jerusalem is considered to be part of the fortification that defended

Jerusalem, during the war campaign of which of the following occupiers/warlords?

A. Ashurbanipal

B. Sargon

C. Tiglath-Pileser

D. Sennacherib


RABBI SCHWARTZ'S ERA’S AND THEIR PLACES AND PEOPLE IN ISRAEL OF THE WEEK


Hopes Dashed- 351 BC-  The King is dead. Achashverosh dies and his son, who according to Chazal was the child of his and Esther's thus making him Jewish, Darius the Persian becomes King. That year officially concluded the 70 years from the destruction of the Temple by Nevuchadnezzar and thus immediately the Jews with the urging of the prophets Chagai and Zecharia began work on the building of the Bait Ha'Mikdash. But before we get to that….

 

Let's understand how and why the Jews weren't that into it. What the prophets said. Why it wasn't so pashut. And what the message for us today is. See, because this wasn't the first time that we were being called to this task. It happened many times before this and I believe it's critical for us to appreciate the mind-set of those returnees and non-returnees. It's important for us today.

 

The truth is from the time that Sancherev exiled the 10 tribes, 150 years before the destruction. Yeshaya and other prophets spoke of the redemption and ingathering of Exiles. Chazal tell us that it is for that reason that many of the good kings of Israel were considered to be Mashiach, like Yoshiyahu and Chizkiyahu. In fact, Yirmiyahu Ha'Navi even thought it was the Messianic time and he went to galus to try to bring the 10 tribes back. But we weren't worthy at that time and ultimately the Temple was destroyed. It's as the parsha tells us this week in the tochacha, we have chance after chance and if we don't grab the opportunity, it will get worse.

 

Even with the periods of Exile, there was hope maybe with Gedalia it would be rebuilt. There was hope that Yehoyakim could bring them back. The many moment though was when Cyrus gave the go ahead and Ezra returned with Zerubavel to be the Kohen. Chazal tell us if the Jews would've returned with them it could've all been over. But they didn't. And thus the work was halted it was put on pause. The children of Haman stopped it. The Shomronim made problems. The Jews in Bavel said… see we told you so…" It was another false hope that was crushed.

 

Thus when the time came in the time of Darius once again. Hashem gave Chagai prophecy tell the Jews to return. Chagai turned to the Jewish people and told them this prophecy, but they didn't buy it. What was their tayna? Sit back and hold your seats and tell me if this sounds familiar…

 

They claimed there were no miracles, like Egypt, and this was supposed to be even greater than then. They claimed that we were still in Galus. That the nations still ruled over us. That we can't upset them. Hashem through the earlier prophets spoke of a period when we will be at rest from our enemies and we're not. This is not like the period of Shlomo Ha'Melech. This is not what we were waiting for. They wanted a supernatural redemption and this wasn't it.

 

Sounds familiar? Sounds 2026. It's good to know history and Tanach. What was Hashem's response through Chagai. Let's see next week. 

 

RABBI SCHWARTZ’S TERRIBLE AFTERLIFE JOKES OF THE WEEK

 

I have like 50 jokes about the unemployed. Trouble is, none of them work.

 

I’m unemployed and asked my friend for advice.

He told me: “Get a job at NASA, they always have space.”

 

Why couldn't the unemployed teacher see? She had no pupils!!

 

My wife and I are both unemployed. My mum died in a car crash. We have three children and we're all staying in my grandma's place, and my grandma died this week. My dad has to work at 73. I'll do any job to take care of my family. Please share.

Sincerely,

William, Prince of Wales

 

I hate it when engineering students refer to themselves as engineers...

Like you don't see med students calling themselves doctors or arts students calling themselves unemployed.

 

My wife didn't leave me because I'm lazy, overweight and jobless. She left me because I don't know anything about baseball.

That was strike four

 

Why can't you trick an unemployed jester? Because he's nobody's fool!

 

What do you call an Apple employee who got laid off? Steve Jobless!

 

Being unemployed is horrible. I never thought I'd lose my job as a psychic.

 

Common synonyms of unemployed. Writer, blogger, and activist.

 

University: just the same as being unemployed. But your parents are proud of you.

 

The number of unemployed musicians today...Is disconcerting

 

People ask whether I’ll make cheese in my afterlife. I tell them, “There’s no whey in hell.

 

Ok, I admit it. I’m an unemployed leather worker. I’ve got nothing to hide.

 

I have 50 jokes about the unemployed. the thing is none of them make any cents

*******************************

The answer to this week's question is D– Finally! An easy one to get me out of this 50/50 rut I'm in. I'm not a big architecture guy or know many of the monuments. But Andartat Ha'Negev is a pretty famous one, commemorating the soldiers of the Negev brigade of the Palmach that fell in 1948.The second part as well is pretty easy. Tanch is one of my stronger points and the Broad wall in the Rova is where we tell the story of the Pesach night siege and miracle of Sancherevs army that were killed by an angel when we woke up the next morning.  So full point for me on this one and the new score is Rabbi Schwartz having 22 points and the MOT having 9 points on this latest Ministry of Tourism exam.

Thursday, May 19, 2016

Poli-Si- Behar 2016 5776

Insights and Inspiration
from the
Holy Land
from
Rabbi Ephraim Schwartz
"Your friend in Karmiel"

May 20th 2016 -Volume 6, Issue 33 11h Iyar 5776
Parshat Behar

Poli -Si
Ok it’s time for some political science here in our weekly E-Mail. The elections are coming up. There are two distinct parties. I hate all three candidates that are left in the field. See in Israel it’s not as much of a problem. I hate all the candidates here as well. But here we vote for a party. I like parties. They’re fun. So I pick the party that best represents my ideology and I’m done. I pretend to turn a blind eye to the crooks and con artists and self-interested politicians that ultimately distort and subvert the message and ideology of their parties. Some to get a chance at getting photo-op on the Rose Garden with whatever sitting president, some for the chance at an (ig) Nobel Peace Prize, and some just to get extra money, honor, or a good shidduch for their children and the fawning of some big Rabbis. I ignore the realities of how these people play out. After-all they’ll probably end up in jail anyways soon. It’s where all good Israeli politicians end up eventually. We have a lot of empty space in our prisons since it seems we’re letting all out all the terrorists and murderers anyways. So we might as well put our prisons to good use and make them a retirement center for aging crooked politicians. That way we can make room for the aspiring new generation of them. And like I said I like parties.
But American politics are different. You vote for the president. I have bitten my tongue in the past and voted for people I did not like. But this year I’m having a hard time even doing that. A megalomaniac nut-  job, and possible misogynistic racist, a lying Arab loving, Arafat-kissing (sorry I can’t get that image out of my mind) power hungry, stilted wife who has stuck with her cheating husband merely to further her own career and blindly driven ambition or a socialist religiously clueless Jew who is bound to sell out his own people and country just to prove what a goy he can be. Sigh…It’s not even a question of the lesser of which evil. Rather it is which one do I think will pretty much bring the end to that once great country America sooner. Like the Egyptians, Babylonians, Greeks, Romans, French, Russians and Turks before them, the great world empire is pretty much getting ready to wrap up shop. It will be interesting to see if the Jewish people and the State of Israel will rise up to fill that void that keeps opening up for us to fill. I’m not too hopeful that we can do it on our own. I am even more hopeful that Mashiach will come and help us get our act together. It would really stink for all those stubborn American Jews to head off to Canada or even China rather than to come home and make it happen. But hey we’ve done stupider things before in our history.
So let’s talk political science for a minute or two. Let’s pretend that in America you could vote for the party. Republican or Democrat which platform is more in line with our Torah’s values? Now the concept of ‘more’ in line is really an oxymoron your either in line or you’re not in line. Your either driving in your lane or your out of your lane. There’s really not much room for grey in the incredible clear system that the Torah describes. And being that the Torah is based on the notion of God and religion defining our system of governance, the American system which is based on the principle of separation of ‘church and State” is already out of line. Don’t get me wrong, the Torah is all for keeping the church out of State and in truth out of this world as well. It is in fact quite clearly fundamentally premised on really getting rid of all the false ‘religious’ systems and fallacies out there. We may not be obligated to wipe them out or kill them-certainly not outside of Israel and certainly not today without the benefit of a King, a court system or in our period of Exile. But we are unquestionably meant to decry the falsehood and the desecration of Hashem’s name that is being distorted by every other faith system. We were put on this earth and our chosen nation status is that we are meant to teach and inspire the world with our ultimate truth, the revelation we alone received on Mt. Sinai. So a system that is based on the premise that religion and Judaism should not play a role in defining the principles of how it is run is already fundamentally flawed.
At the same time the concept of freedom of religion worked out pretty well for the Jewish people. Most places that we have been in our long exile, that had a state based religion ended up killing or expelling us a lot quicker. The freedoms that Jews have had in the US of A are pretty historic and I certainly have a lot of love and patriotism for my birth country and appreciation for it serving as a fairly comfortable resting place for my people until we get to where we need to. Which is why it saddens me somewhat to seeing them go down the tubes so quickly. But hey, let’s not fool ourselves. Let’s not forget our history. 200 years or so is not a bad run for us to hang out in a place.
But I keep digressing. So let’s take the platforms. Conservatism which is pretty much the Republican platform(-although I know that some tea-party and real political scientists may rightfully disagree, but I’m try to keep this simple. There are after-all jokes to get to at the bottom of this E-mail-) is defined by that great source of all wisdom, Wikipedia, as being
“a broad system of political beliefs that is characterized by respect for American traditions, anti-communism, advocacy of American exceptionalism and a defense of Western culture from perceived threats posed by creeping socialism, moral relativism, multiculturalism, and liberal internationalism. Conservatives support capitalism and free market. American conservatives usually place individual liberty as the fundamental trait of democracy, which contrasts with liberals, who generally place a greater value on social equality and social justice for minorities, and the welfare state, and emphasize the need for state intervention to achieve these goals”
OK let’s take this apart. I don’t know what ‘American traditions’ are. I am a fan of apple pie and I respect a good one. I’m not a baseball fan though, although my son is, yet I don’t know if that is something I should respect. Just because a guy could hit a ball with a stick very far and gets paid millions to do it doesn’t mean he should get respect. Although it is pretty impressive that he is able to make that kind of money for seemingly not much intellectual accomplishment. I certainly don’t respect Chevrolet, let’s not fool ourselves the Japanese do the car thing better.
But moving on. I don’t like communists- they killed Jews, although I don’t think it’s a threat anytime soon. ‘American exceptionalism’-hey why not? Not that I think it’s exceptional in all areas but it’s always a good thing to praise the country that’s good to you. ‘Defending western culture from the perceived threats’ is kind of an obtuse statement. Yes there are serious threats facing the US, and yes I think that they should be defended against; although I don’t know if I would include ‘multiculturalism’ as one of them. Sadly a country that won’t allow a Torah perspective to run and direct its defense though is ill equipped to do so. And I’ve never been a fan of ill equipped defenses. Generally that just delays the inevitable defeat.
‘Liberty’ is a good thing-in fact that’s what this week’s Torah portion is about. But as we will see, a Jewish perspective of individual liberty not the fundamental trait of our Torah governance, but rather as a part of the greater picture of communal responsibility and commitment to our religious values. Additionally our values certainly believe- and even at the expense of individual liberty- in the notions of social justice, welfare state and even state and government intervention. So I’m pretty sure I’m not a Republican, although like I said I do like apple pie.
Let’s take the next team, the Democrats, a party that certainly traditionally always had the Jewish vote. It’s kind of hard to define their platform historically as they’ve changed a lot over the years. After all they were the ones that opposed the abolition of slavery and it was Eisenhower a Republican that pushed through the Civil rights act that was opposed for years by LBJ the Democrat (who did eventually vote for it) and it passed with a much greater Republican support then Democratic. Economically as well the Democrats were against the Reconstructionist efforts of the Republicans government intervention after the civil war and were opposed to ‘Big government’ until WWI and FDR’s New Deal. So it’s hard to pin them down. But let’s for a moment take a look at the new current wave of Social Democracy that Bernie is touting and I suspect that Hillary is in line with as well. Again to the Wikipedia Rebbe
‘Social democracy is a political ideology that supports economic and social interventions to promote social justice within the framework of a capitalist economy, and a policy regime involving collective bargaining arrangements, a commitment to representative democracy, measures for income redistribution, regulation of the economy in the general interest and welfare state provisions. Modern social democracy is characterized by a commitment to policies aimed at curbing inequality, oppression of underprivileged groups, and poverty; including support for universally accessible public services like care for the elderly, child care, education, health care and workers' compensation.’
Now how does this sound to you? I like the framework of capitalism part, as we all know that communism and the removal of the profit incentive doesn’t work. I am also a fan of curbing inequality, oppression and poverty-particularly my own. If Social democrats wanna help me or my synagogue out we’re here for you. Certainly as well the premise of income redistribution and correcting income inequality are also not necessarily foreign concepts to a Torah perspective. We are the ones that invented the concepts of the tithing system, of leaving portions of ones field for the needy, of creating institutions of learning and free education for all. The torah in fact and our sages felt the need to legislate all of these things. We can’t trust people to be good and generous on their own. So what can be wrong with a system like this?
I think my problem and perhaps the Torah’s problem is with the social aspect of this engineering. For a man to limit and take money from the rich to disburse to the poor is stealing. For a government, particularly if it is based on the will and ‘revolution of the people’ to do so as well is a recipe for disaster. Remember the French Revolution? The communist Revolution? The peasants, the proletariat, the plebes never really became a better society the just replaced the bourgeois they overthrew.
But leave history aside, the system won’t work. For if I work hard and make it and this guy is just sitting on his laurels and waiting lazily for his handout and he receives all of the benefits that I do, what motivation is there for someone to innovate, to work harder, to produce to get a job, to change the world and achieve the fulfillment of his Divine mandate. I think it is quite telling that despite the fact that Sweden and Denmark have half the poverty rate as the United States does, yet their unemployment rate is higher and they certainly are not even close to the US or any capitalist country in terms of innovation, productivity and even education.
The truth is this thing about equality also troubles me. On one hand we certainly believe that all individuals are equal before the eyes of our Creator, after all we are His kids. We brought that notion to the world. Yet, unlike the Social Democrats we believe there are certainly different roles and limitations that each of has and are meant to play. Roles that prohibit some people from doing things that others can. Roles that are different because of gender, because of lineage, roles that are even different because of deformities and disabilities. It doesn’t mean we’re not equal. It doesn’t mean we are less special. It means that we are just different and our Creator has designed unique roles for each of us to achieve our fullest potential. We each have our own purpose that we are meant to realize, our own piece of fixing the world that only we can do, our won portion in the world to come and our own portion in the Torah. We each have our own bathrooms as well- sorry I couldn’t resist and this E-mail is getting too long without a joke-That appreciation of our differences and our different roles and our responsibilities is what I think is lacking in their perspective and that will ultimately serve as the reason why their system is doomed to failure.
But even more than that troubles with me. I don’t trust people that read the New York Times. I don’t trust people that look at others as morally inferior because I don’t buy into their self-developed visions of what morality is. This is especially true if their morality for the most part is premised on the lack of recognition of God, His Hand in all that runs in this world, and the superior notion that those morally elite are more qualified to engineer society then us primitive God-believing and fearing citizens. When in fact socialist parties and the generally atheistic or at least agnostic leadership has usually turned out to be just as, if not more corrupt and morally bankrupt not only in their personal lives but in their positions of power as the rest of their counterparts. The fact that most of them are so double standard and so removed from the reality of what Israel is facing and the lies of the UN, the Arab world and the threat that fundamental radical Islam poses to the world also prevents me from ever considering to give them my vote.
So I’m stuck. I look at this week’s Torah portion and it’s first words that introduce the laws of the Sabbatical year; that year which even Social Democrats could never come up with. When every single field owner opens up his field for an entire year for anyone to come and take what they want, that every loan, debt and mortgage that I have becomes null and void, and I understand what the Torah is telling me in 2016.
“And Hashem spoke to Moshe on Mt. Sinai saying”
The famous Rashi on this verse says
What does Shemitta/ the Sabbatical year have to do with Sinai weren’t all the commandments said on Sinai? -rather it is to teach you that just as Shemitta and its laws and its fine details were given on Sinai so to all the laws were.”
I am even more astounded by the Torah’s command that in the 50th- Yovel/Jubilee year besides the regular laws of Shemitta any land I purchased returns to its original owners. I have to move out of my rightfully purchase dhouse that I have been living in for the past 49 years and hand it over to that shlub down the  block who can’t even take care of his own field. Huh? Why? Because I understand that the Land is Hashem’s to decide. Not mine. The premise for any law, any ‘social engineering’ can only work because Hashem who gave us this land directs us how to use it. It needs the God component, otherwise it can’t and won’t work.
I read the various incredible laws that are so anti-democratic and anti-republican that the Torah talks about how one should preferably do business with a fellow Jew, rather than who is not Jewish, as the verse says
“When you make a sale to your fellow or when you buy from the hand of your fellow, do not victimize your brother
Our sages derive that this is a mitzva to preferably do business with a Jew, your brother. This would rightfully be considered discriminatory and there is no nation that has ever suffered more from that type of discrimination then the Jewish people historically. Yet the Torah thus commands. It was given on Sinai. It is from the Creator and Father of all mankind that loves all of His children equally and wishes to build a unique special bond between His chosen children that are meant to represent Him to the rest of the world. Think of it as a Divine preferred shoppers only club. Discriminatory? You tell me.
These same club members are obligated to bail out their brother. Obligated! They are prohibited from charging them interest for any loan that they give them. Prohibited! They are obligated to find a job for the unemployed and when they can’t afford to pay for their bills to you and are forced to indenture themselves to you for a limited time it is your obligation to not only support him but his entire family as well and to never have him do any demeaning work- as Rashi explains carrying your stuff after you or helping you put on your shoes. You have to treat him as any other worker that is in your factory, despite the fact that you are paying for his whole families’ entire upbringing. No union would be able to pull off those terms.
You can only hire him for a certain amount of years until the Yovel comes and must assist him in gaining redemption. In fact you are obligated to redeem him from a non-Jewish owner. Get that? A Jew is obligated to take his hard earned money and provide and raise up and redeem even a Jew that has left his faith and has gotten himself into trouble. I am forbidden from turning my eye and from closing my wallet. I am forbidden not only from ever demeaning him but I am obligated to restore him to his former dignity. These laws don’t make sense unless you understand that they were given by Hashem. That the function of these mitzvos is to understand that
“the children of Israel are servants to Me, whom I have taken of the Land of Egypt- I am Hashem”.
Our Parsha as well discusses idolatry the obligation to eradicate it, to have awe of the Temple, to observe the Shabbos, all of these ‘religious laws’ come with the death penalty. There is no religious freedom or liberty in the Torah society. Because it is not about social justice. It is about Divine justice. It is about bringing the world to a recognition that it has a Creator. That the Jew has a Master that he dedicates his entire life to listening to. That this Master is kind, is just, loves His children has created the world for their benefit. That these mitzvas were not made up by popular votes, by Primaries or Supreme courts or through any type of man-made democratic system. Rather they were given to us on Sinai. It’s not something you’ll get in a Poli Sci class, rather in a Poli Sinai class. Those are the elections that will count.
In our daily Amida/Shemona Esrei prayer and blessings when ask Hashem for our personal requests, He is described as many different things. He is Holy. He bequeaths knowledge. He is gracious and forgiving. He is our Redeemer and the Healer of the sick. Yet there is only one blessing that Hashem is described as loving something. In the blessing that we ask for the return to our former leadership, where we ask Hashem to remove from us the grief and despondency of that void of a Divine spiritual God driven leadership. We conclude the blessing with ‘Blessed are You Hashem the King who loves Charity and Justice.’ This blessing is the prelude to the blessing of the request for the great shofar to return the exiles back home. It is the prelude the return of Hashem to Jerusalem, the city he has already returned us to, but yet has to come back to. Hashem loves the principles of charity and justice that He gave to the world through his leaders, because it is only when the fallacies of all the other systems come to the forefront will we be ready to come back home.
We’re there boys and girls. If you haven’t started turning your eyes up to heaven and praying that He finally return us to that only system where His great Name will be recognized and made great in this world. If you still somehow are trying to fit and find yourself and our values in any of the political constructs that are out there or in the representation of any of their proponents or candidates, you’re selling yourselves, the world and Him short. Since there’s really no one to vote for this year anyways, I have an idea for the upcoming election. How about filling in God on your ballot. How about telling the world what- Who we are truly meant to be voting for. What we are praying for. Who really has our vote. That shouldn’t be harder than writing in Trump or Hillary. Should it?
Have an outstanding Shabbos,
Rabbi Ephraim Schwartz

************************************

RABBI SCHWARTZ’S VIDEO OF THEWEEK

https://youtu.be/fs2vFiR0bUwAwesome video of NY Jews going to Morroco really cool scenes, customs, grave of son of Shlomo, and the Bais Hamikdash replica there..

https://youtu.be/FfrSKJ2xgS4 HaRabi acapella version

https://youtu.be/uRcc9wd1Cdw -Leiner Yodat another one of my favorite songs acapella version with blinkers as well! 


RABBI SCHWARTZ’S FAVORITE YIDDISH PROVERB OF THE WEEK
                                                                                  
“Eyn oyg hot mer gloybn vi tsvey oyern”- Trust one eye more than two ears.

RABBI SCHWARTZ'S JEWISH PERSONALITY AND HIS QUOTES IN HONOR OF THE YARTZEIT  OF THE WEEK

“You have friends some will rebuke you and some will praise you Love the rebukers and hate the praisers for the rebukers will bring you to the next world and the praisers will take you out of this world”

“‘When a man comes into the world his hands are clenched tight as if to say that the entire world is mine- I will inherit it. And when he leaves the world, his hands are open wide as if to say I have not inherited anything from this world”

“Even a non-Jew that studies Torah is like a Kohen Gadol/High Priest”

“He who studies Torah and does not teach has desecratd the Name of Hashem.”

"A man should always be accustomed to saying all that Hashem does is for good”

Rabbi Meir Baa;HaNes 14th of Iyar 121 CE this Sunday

RABBI MEIR BAAL HANEIS (Rabbi Meir, Master of Miracles) was a great sage who lived in the Mishnaic era. The name Meir, meaning "Illuminator" in Hebrew, was given to him because he “enlightened” the eyes of scholars in Torah study and to know the light of G-d. The epithet ‘Baal Haneis’ means "the master of miracles” which was added due to the wondrous miracles that G-d performs in his merit.

At the end of 66 CE, there was a Jewish revolt in Judea stemming from Greek and Jewish religious tension. According to the Talmud, Nero Claudius Caesar (37-68 CE) fifth and last Roman Emperor of the Julio-Claudian dynasty, wanted to lead his army into battle against Jerusalem. He wished to determine if he would be successful in destroying her. He therefore shot arrows in all four directions. Miraculously they all fell towards Jerusalem. He took this as a heavenly sign that he would be victorious. He then asked a passing child to repeat the Scriptural verse he had learned that day. The child quoted a verse in Ezekiel 25-14 "I will take revenge of Edom, through the Jewish people". Nero became terrified. He said to himself, "G-d wants me to destroy His House and later avenge Himself in me!" Nero decided to flee to Rome and convert to Judaism to avoid Divine retribution. Vespasian was then dispatched in his stead to put down the rebellion. Jewish tradition reports that Rabbi Meir was a descendant of Emperor Nero.

Rabbi Meir studied under Rabbi Yishmael and then under Rabbi Akiva. He also studied under the famed scholar Elisha ben Avuya, who after becoming a heretic, renouncing the the concepts of Divine reward and punishment and becoming extremely anti-religious the rabbis of the Talmud refrained from relating teachings in his name and referred to him as Acher, the "Other One". Rabbi Meir however continued studying under him while at the same time using their relationship to implore him incessantly to repent his ways and return to the fold. When Elisha was on his deathbed Rabbi Meir was there and one last time begged him to repent. Elisha asked "After all I have done, will I still be accepted? Rabbi Meir said: Is it not written: You return a person to dust (Psalm 90:3) which means, even to the point that a life is ground to the dust one can return. Elisha ben Abuya cried and died. Rabbi Meir rejoiced and said "It seems to me that my teacher departed in a moment of repentance". When they buried him, a fierce fire came and began to burn his grave. They came and told Rabbi Meir: Your teacher's grave is burning. Rabbi Meir went out and spread his Tallis over Elisha's grave and prayed. The fire died down. When later generations questioned how it was permitted for Rabbi Meir to continue studying under Elisha even after he had soured, the response was given that Rabbi Meir was very great and he was able to take only the good and reject the bad.
Rabbi Meir became one of the greatest of the Tannaim. There are three hundred and thirty five laws in the Mishnah that are explicit quotes in the name of Rabbi Meir. In addition there is a rule in the Talmud that all anonymously authored opinions in the Mishnah are attributed to Rabbi Meir. One of the sages of the Talmud, Rav Acha Bar Chanina said There is no question that Rabbi Meir was the greatest scholar of his generation. Nevertheless, the final Halacha is not necessarily established according to his opinion because he was so brilliant, the greatest sages of his generation could not plumb the depth of his great genius and wisdom."
Rabbi Meir was married to Beruriah, one of the few women cited in the Talmud and famous for her great brilliance and wisdom. She was the daughter of Rabbi Chananiah ben Teradyon, one of the ten Jewish leaders martyred by the Roman Government. The Roman Government ordered that Rabbi Chanina and his wife be executed for teaching Torah publicly. They also decreed that their younger daughter (Beruriah's sister) be placed in a brothel. Beruriah asked Rabbi Meir to save her sister. Rabbi Meir took a bag of gold coins and went to the brothel disguised as a Roman horseman. He offered the money as a bribe to the guard. The guard replied, "When my supervisor comes, he will notice the prisoner missing and kill me." Rabbi Meir replied that when you are in danger - say the words, "God of Meir - answer me" and you will be saved." The guard wondered, "How can I be guaranteed that this will save me?" Rabbi Meir replied, "Look! There are man-eating dogs over there. I will go over to them and you will see for yourself." Rabbi Meir walked towards the dogs. They ran over to tear him apart. He cried out "God of Meir - answer me!", and the dogs retreated. The guard was thus convinced and handed over the girl to Rabbi Meir. When the brothel prison supervisors came, the guard bribed them with the money. Eventually, the money was exhausted, and the guard's deed was publicized. The government arrested the guard and sentenced him to death by hanging. When they tied the rope around his neck he cried out "God of Meir - answer me!" The rope tore and the guard escaped.
Rabbi Meir suffered great personal tragedy. He had two sons and a daughter. When his two dear sons suddenly passed away on the Sabbath, his wife Beruriah covered them and hid the news from him so as not to sadden him on this holy day. After the Sabbath she asked him, "What if someone gave me a great treasure to hold for him and he now demands that I return it, must I give it back?" "Of course" he replied, not realizing what she was leading up to. She took his hand and led him into the room where the two dead children lay. When she removed the cover and he realized the great tragedy, he began to cry. She confronted him "Didn't you just say that we must return the treasure to its owner? G-d gave them to us and now G-d took them back. May His name be blessed". In fact, you my dear husband taught that "one is required to bless G-d for the bad just like for the good." (Talmud, Berachot 48).
Rabbi Meir Baal Haneis passed away on the 14th day of the Hebrew month of Iyar. He is buried on the shores of Lake Kinneret, only a short distance from the city of Tiberius. The grave of Rabbi Meir Baal Haneis is one of the holiest sites in the Jewish world and thousands of people flock there to pray for their salvation.
Before his death, Rabbi Meir Baal Haneis promised - as his legacy to all generations - that he will personally intercede in Heaven, on behalf of anyone in distress, who will give charity to the poor in Israel in his memory.
To this very day it has been a sacred and hallowed tradition for Jews, in crisis or need, to recite the words “God of Meir - answer me!” while giving Tzedakah. Countless stories abound of men and women who during a personal crisis, experienced miraculous help when they gave charity to this holy fund in memory of Rabbi Meir Baal Haneis.

RABBI SCHWARTZ'S TOUR GUIDE EXAM QUESTION OF THE WEEK
answer below at end of Email
Q. Harun al-Rashid belongs to the dynasty of:
A.    Umayya 
B.  Abbas
C.  Fatimids
D.  Ayyubids
  
RABBI SCHWARTZ'S COOL RASHI OF THE WEEK
Ok this is not me. This is Rashi talking. OK this is not Rashi talking this is his understanding of the simple understanding of the Torah. OK it’s not only Rashi its in fact a Gemara, the Midrash and other sources. Pretty much it’s Hashem. So don’t blame me. I’m just the messenger. I’m just underlining a Rashi that I’m sure you read this week as you reviewed the weekly Parsha. Don’t blame me.
The verse in this week’s Parsha says as follows
“I am Hashem Your God that I took you out of the land of Egypt to give you the land of Canaan to be for you as Elokim-God”
Rashi explains-
 ‘That anyone who lives in Eretz Yisrael I am for Him God, and he ho leaves it is as if he is worshiping other gods.’
Seemingly Rashi is noting the fact that the Torah enunciates the idea that I am Hashem your God is not a separate notion That Hashem took us out of Egypt merely to be our God. Rather he took us out to give us the land of Israel because only there can I be your God. If you live there I am your God if you don’t or worse leave there for the benefits and alternative ‘benefits’ and are willing to give up on that notion of Hashem being your god that can only happen in Israel-the you are no different than an idolator. The Talmud in Kesuvot calls someone who lives outside of the land is compared to someone who ‘has no god’. Ouch! Don’t blame me it’s the Rabbis in the Talmud.
 Our sages write even more harshly then Rashi the Tosefta in Avodah Zarah (5:2) that states as follows: “One should dwell in Israel even in a city where the majority of the population are idolaters rather than in the Diaspora in a city inhabited completely by Jews. This teaches us that living in Israel is equivalent to all the commandments of the Torah.” Meaning even if one’s Torah is greater, even if one’s education might better, certainly if it is only ones comfort level or livelihood is better. It is better to live in Eretz Yisrael rather than Chutz La’Aretz- the Diaspora- despite the fact that it might be halachically permissible to leave for those reasons. The proof the Talmud brings to this is that King David who left Israel to flee for his life referred to himself as an idolator for doing so, despite that it was certainly permissible to do so. Incidentally the opposite is true as well that despite the fact that one is living in a city that is full of gentiles, where there is so much danger of assimilation and connecting with them and losing one’s faith it is better to be in that situation then to live in the greatest Torah community in America, in the Diaspora, in a country where you are considered as if you have no god. That’s not me talking it’s a Rashi, it’s our sages, it’s the Torah. If you don’t get it. Maybe you don’t have a god. What did you think when you learned this Rashi? This Pasuk? I’m just asking. I would never offer my opinion…


RABBI SCHWARTZ'S COOL HISTORICAL EVENT THAT HAPPENED ON THIS DATE IN ISRAEL OF THE WEEK-

14th  of Iyar May 11th 1960- Capture of Adolph Eichman Y’MSH-Agents of Israel's "Mossad" (Secret Service) captured Nazi leader Adolf Eichmann, chief architect of Hitler’s iniquitous “Final Solution,” in Buenos Aires, Argentina. Eichmann was in charge of all transportation required for the shipment of Jews to the extermination camps and implementing the "final solution" i.e. the extermination of the Jews. The height of his career was reached in Hungary, 1944, when he managed to transport 400,000 Jews to the gas chambers in less than five weeks, r”l. After the war, Eichmann fled to Argentina and lived under the assumed name of Ricardo Klement for ten years until Israeli Mossad agents abducted him on May 11, 1960 and smuggled him out of the country to stand trial in Yerushalayim for his crimes against the Jewish people, crimes against humanity and war crimes. Eichmann was captured through the efforts of Nazi hunter Simon Wiesenthal and the Israeli Mossad . He was put on trial in Israel, which was broadcast worldwide and featured the wrenching testimony of over one hundred witnesses, many of them Holocaust survivors. During the four months of the trial, Eichmann took the stand and used the defense that he was just obeying orders. "Why me," he asked. "Why not the local policemen, thousands of them? They would have been shot if they had refused to round up the Jews for the death camps. Everybody killed the Jews."
Eichmann was found guilty on all counts of crimes against humanity, convicted and sentenced to death by hanging. He was hanged at Ramleh Prison, on 27 Iyar 5722 - May 31, 1962, the only capital punishment ever carried out in Israel. His body was cremated and ashes scattered at sea, so that no nation would serve as Eichmann's final resting place.

RABBI SCHWARTZ'S POLITICAL JOKES OF THE WEEK

What is the difference between Capitalism and Socialism? Capitalism is the exploitation of man by man…Socialism is the exact opposite

The word 'politics' is derived from the word 'poly', meaning 'many', and the word 'ticks', meaning 'blood sucking parasites'. 

Here’s some great Ronald Reagan lines
“Politics is supposed to be the second oldest profession. I have come to realise that it bears a very close resemblance to the first.”
“The government's view of the economy could be summed up in a few short phrases: If it moves, tax it. If it keeps moving, regulate it. And if it stops moving, subsidize it'. 
“'I have left orders to be awakened at any time in case of national emergency, even if I'm in a cabinet meeting'. 
Other great Politic Quotes
Politicians are people who, when they see light at the end of the tunnel, go out and buy some more tunnel.
Politics is the gentle art of getting votes from the poor and campaign funds from the rich, by promising to protect each from the other. 

And finally one last Obama joke
Barak Obama is out jogging one morning, notices a little boy on the corner with a box. Curious he runs over to the child and says, 'What's in the box sonny?' To which the little boy says, 'Kittens, They're brand new kittens.'
Obama laughs and says, 'What kind of kittens are they?  'Democrats', the child says.
'Oh that's lovely, 'Obama smiles and he runs off.
A couple of days later Obama is running with his colleague George Bush and he spies the same boy with his box just ahead. Obama says to Bush, 'Watch this.' and they both jog over to the boy with the box.
Obama says, 'Look in the box George, isn't that cute? Look at those little kittens. Hey son, tell my friend George what kind of kittens they are.'
The boy replies, 'They're Republicans.'
'What?' Obama says, 'I jogged by here the other day and you said they were Republicans. What's changed? 'Well, 'the child says, 'Their eyes are open now.'

:**************

Answer is B – I don’t even stand on a chance on this question. I don’t even know if I did when I was studying for my exams. But certainly not now. After I passed my exam I deleted all information that I knew I would never need again. I have a small brain and a limited amount of space and frankly  I don’t care about the names or figures of all of the various arab dynasties and I still don’t. So I googled the answer for those of you that care and for my daughter Rivka who started cheating every Erev Shabbos and checking the E-Mail to see the answer to the weekly question. So that she knows it and ‘wins’ by the Shabbos table each week. But I’m on to her. I figure she doesn’t read this part of the answer so I guess we’ll find out this week. I guess I’ll find out if any of you read this far as well. If you do I’m impressed. Kol HaKavod